Comparison between Owncloud and Seafile

at first, sorry for my bad english.

3 years ago we used Dropbox. But more and more customer data had to be available for us on the “road”. So Dropbox wasn’t the right service anymore. One of the first alternatives was seafile (tested before owncloud) and since then we used this cool cloud-server on our own hyerrV server. So i can’t say much about owncloud.

Maybe someone else can highlight his own experiences with ownlcloud.

at the moment we have 3 happy customers, using seafile for all their documents and teamworking on that.

seafile pros:

  • easy installation (if you’re firm with linux cli)
  • very, very, very stable and fast!!! (i red much comments about slow owncloud clients)
  • integrated snapshot-system/versioning/trash for changed files/folders … as long as you want
  • multiple sharing options with external or internal users
  • possibility to register yourself on the webinterface (with admin approval)
  • nice webinterface (see screenshots) and client-software
  • clients for all platforms (win,mac,linux,android,ios)
  • user-db options (sqlite/sql/ldap)
  • very active development an support (also for community/free serverversion)
  • good documentation for admins (installation and configuration)
  • professional service and hosting (also in germany) available

seafile cons:

  • user-rights management is bit confusing for the first time
  • library (top level folders) and sub-library system (in comparison to normal folders) has first to be unterstand by customer (and admin :blush:) and should be planed very well before create the librarys
  • only a filecloud-server, no contact or calendar sync!, but this is a clear desicion from the developers, there are enough groupware server on the market (imho)

comparison webinterface (also workplace for admin):

owncloud:

seafile:

comparison clients:
owncloud:


seafile:

i found this on https://www.ionas-server.com/blog/owncloud-vs-seafile-performance/

Performance ownCloud vs Seafile (on a Raspberry Pi B+, ionas)

Test: ownCloud | Seafile

Fotos Upload: 0,5 MB/sec. | 2,5 MB/sec.

Fotos Download: 0,5 MB/sec. | 3,0 MB/sec.

ISO Upload: failed | 2,1 MB/sec.

ISO Download: not tested | 3,0 MB/sec.

Grüße

Hardy

4 Likes

I have my thoughts on this topic but I’d like to hear from this people first @a4rgl @marceloeng @cswain @enzoturri @Miko10 @jackyes
@wombat77 thank you for sharing this overview! :ok_hand: and welcome aboard!

i will try seafile in the next days.
we can’t trust a performance test on a raspberry pi! :frowning: :smiley:

PS: OT: will try also Pydio

1 Like

Why not? Extending our comparison.

OwnCloud was my first try with own cloud :slight_smile:. But after one day in the hotel with very bad internet connection, owncloud client deleted my local files and start download whole library. I was in HELL :imp:. This is wrong function. I fonud than some discusions about it, but nothing changed in new version. When it delete my files another time, owncloud was deleted from my server and than I found Seafile. Now I’m using Seafile over one year and everything is OK. So I suggest Seafile to every one. And thanks to versioning I saved many files for my customers with cryptolocker.

1 Like

At this location, we use OwnCloud application on the in-house NethServer. We find it integrates easily and sync with the calendar function in Thunderbird/Lightning. Our main function though is to have a file store where we and our customers can upload/download files, using desktops, tablets, etc. For this requirement it works very well.

Pydio was not suitable for some users, and OwnCloud we thought was better than Seafile for sync. We did look at using others,(cloud versions) like DropBox, Google+, etc, but wanted something that we can control, and could be placed on our own hardware.
NethServer includes a one-click install of OwnCloud, (see here: http://www.nethserver.org/nethserver-owncloud-1-click-install/ ) and with the NethServer community, if things went wrong, there is excellent help available.

We have been using OwnCloud on Nethserver now for about 3 months and it is very stable, upload/download of files from desktops is quick - a 244MB .mp4 file took 7 seconds to upload, and 11 seconds to download, tested using two Mint 17.3 desktops, one for upload, 2nd for download.

We have not had any problems like this; our field engineers use the Hotel’s own connection, however we do use VPNs back to the NethServer, before using OwnCloud.

I’m not sure the following is really relevant, but may help taking a better decision:

3 Likes

O_O

I literally just heard the sound of a car crash in my mind.

But this sounds like all will be well.
http://karlitschek.de/2016/06/nextcloud/

3 Likes

Yeah, Nextcloud is the new kid in town. I wish Nethserver would offer a great base for Nextcloud, once they have their first release

3 Likes

2 posts were split to a new topic: Any opinions about Pydio?

@wombat77 wow, just… WOW
one of the most referred topics ever :scream_cat:

@wombat77 can you update this discussion creating a new one with NextCloud? It would be really great :slight_smile: